In 1999, the Los Angeles Fire Department (LAFD) was losing paramedics faster than it could train or hire replacements (Fox, 1999). The authorized paramedic workforce of 435 had 60 unfilled positions, representing a 14% position vacancy rate. That meant a lot of involuntary hold-overs or “force hire” report-back-to work assignments. To get a month away from the force hire assignments, paramedics had to volunteer to work 96 hours of overtime – called “assign hire” – in the previous month (Williams, 2007).

While working as an Assistant Professor at The George Washington University, I followed the efforts of Los Angeles and Baltimore fire departments as they addressed the challenge of adding ambulances to their overworked systems (2000 – 2007). One element was the impact of authorized but unfilled full-time positions.

In looking at other fire departments, we observed that when the percentage of authorized career positions that are unstaffed exceeds 12%, the number of firefighters or single-role paramedics willing to work the overtime to fill those vacancies plummets. Anecdotal evidence suggests that some fire departments are wrestling with this issue today.

The Impact of Excessive Overtime

John Hicks, writing in The Firemen’s Grapevine, articulated the reality for LAFD employees:

You’re working another 72-hour shift. It’s okay, you’re young. You have a girlfriend/boyfriend, but it is just the beginning of the relationship. You recently bought your first condo, but the payment is low, and your health is good. A little time passes. You are still doing those 72-hour shifts, with an occasional 96-hour now thrown in. Your significant other is now wearing a wedding ring, and your first born is asking you if he or she is going to have a brother or sister soon. The condo was traded for a three-bedroom home in suburbia USA along with the cheaper mortgage. Overtime is now more of a necessity than a luxury.

Due to the abundance of overtime, the days of having a “C” shift job have all but disappeared for LAFD members. Not only has this hurt the department by limiting the talents learned by the experience gained by working other types of job, such as construction, electrical, and plumbing related careers, it means that overtime seems to be the sole means for most to earn a little extra money. (2022)

The Challenge of Fire Department Position Management

There has been a long dance over what staffing a fire department needs to meet its operational requirements. Jurisdiction leadership is resistant to creating new full-time positions, as they require 137% funding to cover salary, workers’ compensation, annual/sick leave, training, personal protective gear, and other human resource expenditures.

The jurisdictional administrators and elected leaders struggle with the concept of having a workforce where there are more full-time equivalents (FTEs) on duty than the minimum required seats to fill. As Fitch and Associates LLC partner Steven Knight, Ph.D., points out:

Using my old department as an example, the staffing was determined on a legacy basis and that legacy pre-dated most, if not all, of the institutional knowledge. For example, the department staffed five personnel for every seat on an engine, four for every seat on a truck company, and two for every seat on a rescue. While the daily minimum staffing was consistently applied, it had to overcome the inconsistency in staffing for each position. In fairness, these legacy-staffing strategies may have been compromises over the years and budget cycles, but to clearly articulate the strategy at a future moment in time proves difficult. (2019)

Looking At LAFD

A 2015 Evergreen Data Library audit of overtime led the Los Angeles City Council to approve hiring 48 additional firefighters. At that time, “420 LAFD employees earned more than $100,000 in overtime, and 19 earned more than $200,000. One Fire Captain made $311,316 in overtime on top of a $120,829 salary, for a staggering total of $448,594 in overtime pay. … a Commander at the LAFD informed the Controller’s office that the employee with $311,316 in overtime did obey all policies and procedures regarding overtime.” Evergreen noted that “Los Angeles uses what is called a ‘constant staffing’ model, which intentionally keeps firefighter positions open and uses overtime to make up for the missing employees. … LAFD is understaffed to the brink of collapse.”

Those 48 additional firefighter positions in 2015 did not end the overtime issue.

An audit of the Fiscal Year 2019 expenditures (July 2018 – June 2019) showed that “Eighteen employees of the Los Angeles Fire Department earned more than $200,000 in overtime pay last fiscal year, with one firefighter making $360,010 in overtime.” The 2019 audit also observed that “More than 90% of sworn police and fire employees last fiscal year received overtime, earning an average of $27,737, while 40% of the city’s general employees, defined as other sworn and civilian workers, received such pay. That group earned an average of $7,528” (Smith, 2019)

In 2022, The Center Square reported, “A captain in the department made $434,394 in overtime in 2021, pushing their gross pay to $598,532 to become the highest-paid employee in the city that year. Another fire captain made $420,055 in overtime, pushing that person’s gross pay to $593,314 in 2021. That person was the second-highest paid employee in the city, according to city payroll records. A firefighter with a base salary of $129,638 made $411,606 in overtime, making that firefighter’s total compensation $554,056. There were 86 employees in the fire department who made $400,000 or more in 2021. However, the highest ranking employee was not among those. The fire chief made $338,624, or nearly $250,000 less than the fire captain.” (Gantert et al., 2022)

The 2021 overtime increases in Los Angeles are linked to multiple-day wildfire campaign operations and the interrupted hiring cycle during the COVID pandemic. Emergency workers are dealing with the lingering effects of a massive increase in disease exposure (opioid overdoses and COVID) and a physically challenging workload. The 2023 Standards of Cover Analysis performed by CityGate Associates LLC made this observation: “The volume and simultaneous demand on the top 10 to top 28 LAFD stations is the highest CityGate has ever measured in a metro client”(Citygate, 2023, p. 6).

ICMA and Center for Public Safety Excellence: 21st Century Fire & Emergency Services

The ICMA and Center for Public Safety Excellence white paper on 21st Century Fire and Emergency Services identified two themes:

• The past strategies of deferring conclusive action on critical issues with short-term solutions and leaving them for the next set of leadership are not a sustainable strategy for the future. To continue to do so will worsen the eventual correction(s) that will have to be made.
• We must begin recruiting talent with the mindset, skill sets, and resolve to help build a core organizational culture that can adapt and respond to rapid changes and that is not vested in a 20th-century fire service paradigm or antiquated local government bureaucracy. (2020)

This white paper may serve as a starting point to change the conversation with jurisdictional leaders and elected officials. We need to develop a new narrative that promotes appropriate organizational staffing to meet the expanded and complex roles that a fire department performs today.

The Impact of Overcommitting Existing Staff

Robert Peterson’s Executive Fire Officer capstone research paper examined employee perceptions of hours worked within the Corona (California) Fire Department (CFD). A ten-year retrospective analysis found overtime was only slightly cheaper than hiring, while daily vacancy levels were high enough to justify additional positions outright and identified fatigue-driven injury risk as the hidden cost. Corona Fire Department documented a 93% increase in injury-related time off alongside a 119% increase in forced hire/mandatory overtime over ten years (2024, p. 6). The vacancy is not eliminated; it is converted into overtime liability, workers’ compensation exposure, and attrition.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) awarded a five-year contract to the National Association of State EMS Officials (NASEMSO) to understand the science of sleep health and apply these principles to develop fatigue risk management guidelines. One of the products is the Implementation Guidebook: 2018 Fatigue Management Guidelines for Emergency Medical Services that recommends EMS personnel work shifts shorter than 24 hours (Patterson & Robinson, 2018, p. 7).

Just before 5:20 a.m. Sunday, April 2, 2023, as BLS 16 responded to a call, it slammed into a power pole, a crosswalk sign, and a wall.  The crew, in the 69th hour of a 72 hour shift, suffered minor injuries.

“Right now, we still have employees who are still dealing with sleep deprivation and knowing that this has been going on for over a year and didn’t come up with concrete solutions to solve it,” said Pritchard.

President Rex Pritchard, Long Beach Firefighters Association Local 372, said he and leaders of the International Association of Machinists Local 1930 have been urging the department to address what they say are extreme call volume and fatigue issues for over a year but haven’t seen any changes.

“What is very common in this department is to work 72-hour shifts,” said Pritchard. “You’re lucky if you get, in that 72 hours, four to six hours of rest.” (CBS LA Staff, 2023)

Changing The Conversation

The fire service has argued about staffing in the same terms for decades: seats, minimums, and the price of one more position. Los Angeles added 48 firefighters in 2015 and, by 2021, had 86 fire department employees earning more than $400,000, with a captain out-earning the fire chief by nearly $250,000. Incremental hiring against a structurally under-authorized workforce does not close the gap; it only changes who is exhausted.

The ICMA and Center for Public Safety Excellence white paper offers a more useful frame, calling for recruitment of talent with “the mindset, skill sets, and resolve to help build a core organizational culture that can adapt and respond to rapid changes” rather than one “vested in a 20th-century fire service paradigm or antiquated local government bureaucracy.” That reframing matters because the fire department is no longer staffed for the mission it actually performs. It is an all-hazards, high-acuity, medically dominant enterprise being resourced by a formula built for structural firefighting.

The new narrative should describe risk exposure, service reliability, and total labor cost rather than in seats and minimums. It should treat fatigue management as a standard of care. And it should be honest that the choice was never between spending and not spending. The choice was between spending deliberately on positions and spending involuntarily on the consequences of leaving them empty. The departments that make that case successfully will be the ones able to staff without force hires in the future.

References

CBS LA staff. (4 April 2023). Long Beach unions say ambulance crash highlights staffing shortage. KCAL CBS. https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/long-beach-unions-say-ambulance-crash-highlights-staffing-shortage/

CityGate. (2023). Los Angeles Fire Department Standards of Cover Analysis. Volume 1 of 3: Technical Report. CityGate Associates LLC.

Evergreen Data Library (2015) Los Angeles – Payroll & Overtime Analysis. https://evergreen.data.socrata.com/stories/s/Los-Angeles-Payroll-Overtime-Analysis/ijhv-thke/

Fox, S. (1999 Dec 26). Proposal Targets Paramedic Shortage. Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-dec-26-me-47674-story.html

Gantert, T., Apel, E., & Rowland, B. (2022, July 18). Los Angeles’ $600,000 fire captain and 86 firefighters made more than $400,000 in 2021. The Center Square. https://www.thecentersquare.com/california/los-angeles-600-000-fire-captain-and-86-firefighters-made-more-than-400-000-in/article_ca6b4cbc-06a8-11ed-9919-679807fe6e61.html

Hicks, J. (2022, April 1) Overtime – Too much of a good thing? The Fireman’s Grapevine. Los Angeles Firemen’s Relief Association. https://www.lafra.org/overtime-too-much-of-a-good-thing/

ICMA & CPSA (2020) 21st Century Fire and Emergency Services. https://www.cpse.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/21st-Century-Fire-and-Emergency-Services-White-Paper-Final-07.15.20.pdf

Knight, S. (2019, March 12). Full time, part time, overtime: How to fill fire department vacancies. FireRescue1.com. https://www.firerescue1.com/fire-chief/articles/full-time-part-time-overtime-how-to-fill-fire-department-vacancies-uRC8dscpvRkfgRhN/

Patterson, P. D., & Robinson, K. (201, October). Implementation Guidebook: 2018 Fatigue Management Guidelines for Emergency Medical Services. National Association of State EMS Officials. https://s3.amazonaws.com/ClubExpressClubFiles/157064/documents/Fatigue_in_EMS_Implementation_Guidebook_1551393887.pdf

Peterson, R. (2024, April). Employee Perceptions of Hours Worked in the Corona Fire Department. [Capstone research project, National Fire Academy]. U.S. Fire Administration. https://apps.usfa.fema.gov/pdf/efop/Robert-Peterson-Employee-Perceptions-of-Hours-Worked-in-the-Corona.pdf

Smith, D. (2019, Nov 6) L.A. firefighter banked $360,010 in overtime pay in one year, city audit finds. Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-11-06/lapd-lafd-audit-overtime-city-controller

Williams, E. (2007 Aug 29). Paramedic Coded Assign Hire to End Sept 9. Battalion 14 News & Information (dormant rss feed).